| Winners | Runners Up | |||
| 1902/03 | Barrow Rising Star | Anstey Town | ||
| 1903/04 | Leicester British Utd | Loughborough Emmanuel | ||
| 1904/05 | Shepshed Alb | Leicester British Utd | ||
| 1905/06 | Earl Shilton Victor | Shepshed Alb | ||
| 1906/07 | Leicester Oxford Vics | Castle Donington Town | ||
| 1907/08 | Castle Donington Town | Barwell Utd | ||
| 1908/09 | R.Walker & Sons | Woodhouse Imps | ||
| 1909/10 | no competition | |||
| 1945/46 | Wellington Vics | Whitwick Colliery | ||
| 1969/70 | Thringstone MW | Hillcroft | ||
| 1970/71 | Thringstone MW | Hillcroft | ||