Honours: Atherstone Town
West Midlands (Regional) League
  Runners Up 1971/72
Birmingham Combination
  Champions 1947/48
  Runners Up 1911/12
Leicestershire & Rutland Challenge Cup
  Runners Up 1959/60

League History: Atherstone Town

League History: Atherstone Town Reserves

Cup History: Atherstone Town

Westerby Challenge Cup

Cup History: Atherstone Town Reserves

Jelson Homes Senior Cup